toppan merrill
  • Insights
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Client Login

    Toppan Merrill Bridge™

    Content Control

    My Workspace

    Form N-MFP Online

    Toppan Merrill Document Delivery

    Toppan Merrill Insurance Solutions

    Section16Direct

    SEC Connect

    SOX Automation

  • EN

    English

    简体中文 (Simplified Chinese)

    繁體中文 (Traditional Chinese)

  •  
  • Capital Markets Transactions
    • Capital Markets Transactions

      Equity, Debt & IPO Offering Management Services

      M&A

       

       

       
       

      Capital Markets Transactions Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      EDGAR Resources

      XBRL Resources

       

       

      Capital Markets Transactions Products

      Bridge

      Built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

       

       

       

  • Regulatory Disclosure
    • Regulatory Disclosure for Corporations

      Annual Meeting & Proxy Solutions

      Annual Meeting & Proxy Consulting

      Periodic & Interim Reporting

      iXBRL and EDGAR for US-GAAP & IFRS Filers

      iXBRL for ESEF Filings

      SEDAR Filings

      Section 16 Filings

      Automated SOX Compliance

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure for Investment Management

      Periodic & Interim Reporting and Prospectuses

      Component Content Management & Output

      Website Document Hosting

      Shareholder Preference Center

      Compliance Center for Variable Products

       

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      EDGAR Resources

      XBRL Resources

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure Products

      Bridge

      Built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

       

       

      SOX Automation

      Intuitive SaaS technology that centralizes all business locations, processes, risks and controls delivering efficiency, transparency, and predictability of cost.

       

       

  • Sales & Marketing Communications
    • Sales and Marketing Communications

      Offerings

      Omni-channel communications

      Document Creation & Management

      Sales Enablement

      ADA Services

      Fulfillment & Distribution

      Printing Services

       

       

       

      Industries

      Financial Services

      Health Insurance

       

       

       

      Sales and Marketing Communications Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

       

       

      Sales and Marketing Communications Products

      Connect

      Drive client engagement and streamline personalized, compliant communications from printing to leading-edge digital solutions.

       

       

       

  • Products
    TOPPAN MERRILL
    ConnectTM

    Connect helps drive client engagement and streamline personalized, compliant communications from printing to leading-edge digital solutions.

    TOPPAN MERRILL
    BridgeTM

    A seamless SaaS solution built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge is an intuitive technology that makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

  • Resources
    •  
       

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      XBRL Resources

      SEC EDGAR Resources, Definitions, and Processes

      Regulatory Compliance Glossary

       

       

       

toppan merrill
  • Capital Markets Transactions
    • Overview
    • Equity, Debt & IPO Offering Management Services
    • M&A
  • Regulatory Disclosure
    • For Corporations

      • Overview
      • Annual Meeting and Proxy Statement Solutions
      • Periodic & Interim Reporting
        • EDGAR & iXBRL for SEC Filings (US-GAAP & IFRS)
        • iXBRL for ESEF Filings
        • SEDAR Filings
        • Section 16 Filings
        • Automated SOX Compliance
    • For Investment

      • Overview
      • Prospectus for Investment Management
      • Periodic & Interim Reporting for Investment Management
        • Component Content Management & Output
        • Website Document Hosting
        • Shareholder Preference Center
        • Portfolio Specific Document Management for Variable Products
  • Sales & Marketing Communications
    • Overview
    • Offerings

      • Omni-Channel Communications
      • Document Creation & Management
      • Sales Enablement
      • ADA Services
      • Fulfillment & Distribution
      • Printing Services
    • Industries

      • Financial Services
      • Health Insurance
      • Dynamic Publishing for Health Insurance
  • Products
    • Connect
    • Bridge
    • SOX Automation
  • Resources
    • Insights & Analysis
    • Events
    • SEC Resources
    • SEC EDGAR Resources
    • XBRL Resources
    • glossary
  • Insights & Analysis
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Client Login
    • Toppan Merrill BridgeTM
    • Content Control
    • My Workspace
    • Form N-MFP Online
    • Toppan Merrill Document Delivery
    • Toppan Merrill Insurance Solutions
    • Section16Direct
 

View From the Big Four: XBRL Quality Gives Your Company a Competitive Advantage

By Toppan Merrill on 12 October, 2020
1 min read | Industry Insights Insights Home

05_Where does XBRL go from here_

As the use of XBRL financial data in the market accelerates, the quality of XBRL tagging in disclosures is no longer solely an SEC compliance issue. It is an integral part of a company’s ability to tell its financial story, attract investment, raise capital, protect its reputation, and keep a sharp competitive edge. Eleven years into the SEC’s XBRL mandate, as financial data is increasingly consumed in structured format, the ever-impatient capital markets are signaling that the grace period is over. Companies risk being left behind if they fail to get their XBRL right.

At the very least, errors in financial statements that reflect poor XBRL quality make the company’s financial data difficult or impossible to analyze—discouraging busy analysts and investors with no time to waste. At the worst, errors raise serious red flags about the company as an investment. Investors and analysts may wonder whether sloppy XBRL mistakes in basic financial reporting are the tip of a much bigger and uglier iceberg in the company’s management and internal controls over financial reporting (ICFR).

Companies materially benefit from high-quality tagging
Despite the clear incentives for getting XBRL tagging right, mistakes continue to plague XBRL data in financial reporting. In a July 15th analysis, The Competitive Advantage of Quality XBRL Data, PwC observes that a whopping 46% of Form 10-K and 10-Q filings filed during the first two weeks of July 2020 had XBRL errors, according to the XBRL US Data Quality Committee.

PwC draws a compelling conclusion from this: XBRL problems at other companies present a competitive opportunity for yours. “XBRL data is used by analysts, credit-risk agencies, industry researchers, investors, regulators, academics, and others to gain insights that influence key decisions. A company that consistently provides high-quality XBRL data can differentiate itself in a crowded marketplace with the credibility gained from high-quality XBRL data.”

In other words, companies can materially benefit from high-quality XBRL tagging. Moreover, an XBRL arms race among companies striving to tag XBRL better than their peers could finally elevate XBRL quality to where it needs to be. In that case, everyone wins. As PwC points out, XBRL data does “benefit the capital markets more broadly because it may result in more efficient and effective decisionmaking.”

How does bad XBRL hurt decisionmaking? PwC succinctly conveys a few ways:

(table reproduced from the article)

Getting XBRL right requires specialized expertise
PwC emphasizes that companies should take ownership of their XBRL with dedicated, specialized expertise, not just a cursory review by a data aggregator. “Because only certain data-quality issues are identified by the aggregators,” the firm cautions, “the responsibility for the quality and usability of XBRL submissions rests with financial statement preparers.”

Obtaining expert review, whether in-house or from a service provider, is no small matter. PwC warns that “preparers who rely on data vendors to identify and correct errors within their XBRL submissions may unintentionally cede control of the narrative analysts and investors use for decision-making.”

Filers now need both accounting and XBRL knowledge
Another Big Four accounting firm focuses on both the detailed 2020 updates to the complex US GAAP taxonomy and the ongoing demands of the SEC’s Inline XBRL mandate. Jeff Naumann and Lou Rohman from Deloitte & Touche indicate (see SEC Updates XBRL Rules for Digital Financial Reporting) that the major changes to the 2020 GAAP taxonomy and the related SEC Reporting Taxonomy include 338 new tags and 324 deprecated tags that should not be used in filings; revisions to retirement benefits in multi-employer plans and to variable interest entities and equity method investments; and transition to ASUs and other accounting changes.

The hefty list of updates to the GAAP taxonomy calls for not only traditional accounting and financial-reporting expertise but also extensive XBRL knowledge. Deloitte warns that the risk of errors naturally rises when filers transition to a new version of the GAAP taxonomy, because “changes made in the new taxonomy may be overlooked.” SEC filers can now voluntarily anchor a custom tag to a base taxonomy tag. Anchoring can be useful for giving clarity to custom tags or more easily replacing unnecessary custom tags. (In the European Union, anchoring is mandatory; see further the reporting manual from the European Securities and Markets Authority, covering the preparation of annual financial reports in Inline XBRL).
Deloitte agrees with PwC about the importance of seeking specialized expertise in structured data to ensure high XBRL quality. “SEC registrants may use third-party vendors, but they retain overall responsibility for their filings. It’s important for registrants to understand how adoption of iXBRL will affect the timing and nature of their filing preparation and review processes, and ensure that they have personnel with appropriate expertise to review the iXBRL formatting.”

To read the full article in Dimensions Vol. 2020, No. 4, click here.


Reach out to jump start a partnership that will bring speed, security, accuracy and efficiency to all of your complex content and communication requirements. 

Contact Us

Share

Share on twitter Share on linkedin Share on facebook
Previous ArticleInline XBRL Insight for Mutual Funds and Variable Contracts
Next ArticleWhy XBRL Should Be on Your Radar

Subscribe

Subscribe

Subscribe

Subscribe

Toppan Merrill


Toppan Merrill, a leader in financial printing and communication solutions, is part of the Toppan Printing Co., Ltd., the world's leading printing group, headquartered in Tokyo with approximately US$14 billion in annual sales. Toppan Merrill has been a pioneer and trusted partner to the financial, legal and corporate communities for five decades, providing secure, innovative solutions to complex content and communications requirements. Through proactive partnerships, unparalleled expertise, continuous innovation and unmatched service, Toppan Merrill delivers a hassle-free experience for mission-critical content for capital markets transactions, financial reporting and regulatory disclosure filings, and marketing and communications solutions for regulated and non-regulated industries. With global expertise in major capital markets, Toppan Merrill delivers unmatched service around the world.


toppanmerrill.com


Show more posts from author

XBRL; SEC; Capital Markets & Compliance; Dimensions; Periodic & Interim Reporting;
 

Expert Support

The best-in-class partner for complex, secure communications. Contact Toppan Merrill today.

Contact Us

Subscribe to the Toppan Merrill Blog

Gain actionable insight on industry trends, best practices & successful strategies to help your business.

Subscribe

Blog Categories

  • Industry Trends
  • Shareholder Communications
  • 40 Act SEC Regulations
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect
  • Content Management
  • Print/Fulfillment

Blog Categories

  • Industry Trends
  • Shareholder Communications
  • 40 Act SEC Regulations
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect
  • Content Management
  • Print/Fulfillment

Blog Categories

  • Member Communications
  • Section 508 Compliance
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect

Blog Categories

  • Industry trends
  • Shareholder communications
  • 40 act SEC regulations
  • Digital communications
  • Toppan Merrill connect
  • Content management
  • Print/fulfillment

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar
Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

ToppanMerrill logo

Expand Possible.

twitter linkedin

Solutions

  • Capital Markets Transactions
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Corporations
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Investment Management Companies
  • Financial Services Marketing & Communications
  • Health Insurance Marketing & Communications
  • Election Services

Technologies

  • Toppan Merrill Connect™
  • Toppan Merrill Bridge™

Blog

  • Insights

About Toppan Merrill

  • About Toppan Merrill
  • Operating Principles
  • Careers

Get In Touch

  • Contact Us

TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY NOTICE | TOPPAN MERRILL SERVICES AGREEMENT | TOPPAN MERRILL SUPPLIERS | GLOSSARY

© Toppan Merrill 2022

ToppanMerrill logo
Expand Possible.
` twitter linkedin
Solutions
  • Capital Markets Transactions
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Corporations
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Investment Management Companies
  • Financial Services Marketing & Communications
  • Health Insurance Marketing & Communications
  • Election Services
Technologies
  • Toppan Merrill ConnecTM
  • Toppan Merrill BridgeTM
BLOG
  • Insights
About Toppan Merrill
  • About Toppan Merrill
  • Operating Principles
  • Careers
Get In Touch
  • Contact Us

TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY NOTICE | TOPPAN MERRILL SERVICES AGREEMENT | TOPPAN MERRILL SUPPLIERS | GLOSSARY

© Toppan Merrill 2019