toppan merrill
  • Insights
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Client Login

    Toppan Merrill Bridge™

    Content Control

    My Workspace

    Form N-MFP Online

    Toppan Merrill Document Delivery

    Toppan Merrill Insurance Solutions

    Section16Direct

    SEC Connect

    SOX Automation

  • EN

    English

    简体中文 (Simplified Chinese)

    繁體中文 (Traditional Chinese)

  •  
  • Capital Markets Transactions
    • Capital Markets Transactions

      Equity, Debt & IPO Offering Management Services

      M&A

       

       

       
       

      Capital Markets Transactions Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      EDGAR Resources

      XBRL Resources

       

       

      Capital Markets Transactions Products

      Bridge

      Built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

       

       

       

  • Regulatory Disclosure
    • Regulatory Disclosure for Corporations

      Annual Meeting & Proxy Solutions

      Annual Meeting & Proxy Consulting

      Periodic & Interim Reporting

      iXBRL and EDGAR for US-GAAP & IFRS Filers

      iXBRL for ESEF Filings

      SEDAR Filings

      Section 16 Filings

      Automated SOX Compliance

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure for Investment Management

      Periodic & Interim Reporting and Prospectuses

      Component Content Management & Output

      Website Document Hosting

      Shareholder Preference Center

      Compliance Center for Variable Products

       

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      EDGAR Resources

      XBRL Resources

       

       

      Regulatory Disclosure Products

      Bridge

      Built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

       

       

      SOX Automation

      Intuitive SaaS technology that centralizes all business locations, processes, risks and controls delivering efficiency, transparency, and predictability of cost.

       

       

  • Sales & Marketing Communications
    • Sales and Marketing Communications

      Offerings

      Omni-channel communications

      Document Creation & Management

      Sales Enablement

      ADA Services

      Fulfillment & Distribution

      Printing Services

       

       

       

      Industries

      Financial Services

      Health Insurance

       

       

       

      Sales and Marketing Communications Resources

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

       

       

      Sales and Marketing Communications Products

      Connect

      Drive client engagement and streamline personalized, compliant communications from printing to leading-edge digital solutions.

       

       

       

  • Products
    TOPPAN MERRILL
    ConnectTM

    Connect helps drive client engagement and streamline personalized, compliant communications from printing to leading-edge digital solutions.

    TOPPAN MERRILL
    BridgeTM

    A seamless SaaS solution built on the Microsoft® Office® platform, Bridge is an intuitive technology that makes disclosure content management easier, faster and more accurate.

  • Resources
    •  
       

      Insights & Analysis

      Events

      SEC Resources

      XBRL Resources

      SEC EDGAR Resources, Definitions, and Processes

      Regulatory Compliance Glossary

       

       

       

toppan merrill
  • Capital Markets Transactions
    • Overview
    • Equity, Debt & IPO Offering Management Services
    • M&A
  • Regulatory Disclosure
    • For Corporations

      • Overview
      • Annual Meeting and Proxy Statement Solutions
      • Periodic & Interim Reporting
        • EDGAR & iXBRL for SEC Filings (US-GAAP & IFRS)
        • iXBRL for ESEF Filings
        • SEDAR Filings
        • Section 16 Filings
        • Automated SOX Compliance
    • For Investment

      • Overview
      • Prospectus for Investment Management
      • Periodic & Interim Reporting for Investment Management
        • Component Content Management & Output
        • Website Document Hosting
        • Shareholder Preference Center
        • Portfolio Specific Document Management for Variable Products
  • Sales & Marketing Communications
    • Overview
    • Offerings

      • Omni-Channel Communications
      • Document Creation & Management
      • Sales Enablement
      • ADA Services
      • Fulfillment & Distribution
      • Printing Services
    • Industries

      • Financial Services
      • Health Insurance
      • Dynamic Publishing for Health Insurance
  • Products
    • Connect
    • Bridge
    • SOX Automation
  • Resources
    • Insights & Analysis
    • Events
    • SEC Resources
    • SEC EDGAR Resources
    • XBRL Resources
    • glossary
  • Insights & Analysis
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Client Login
    • Toppan Merrill BridgeTM
    • Content Control
    • My Workspace
    • Form N-MFP Online
    • Toppan Merrill Document Delivery
    • Toppan Merrill Insurance Solutions
    • Section16Direct
 

100% XBRL Coverage Has Transformed SEC Review and Enforcement

By Toppan Merrill on 19 November, 2019
1 min read | Industry Insights Insights Home

05_Where does XBRL go from here_

Ten years have passed since the SEC’s XBRL requirement came into effect. Despite the challenges of the transition from traditional filing to structured data, using XBRL in SEC financial reporting has proven to be a great success. The use of XBRL-tagged data in financial disclosures continues to accelerate among investors, market analysts, and the SEC staff who conduct review and enforcement activities. It is becoming the norm for the collection and analysis of financial data.

The SEC’s vast structured database is transforming and improving the way financial disclosures tell companies’ stories to investors. It is solving the two problems the SEC sought to address with the XBRL mandate: The need to make the ever-expanding universe of corporate financial information more easily accessed by investors who are facing investment decisions; and the need to regulate this data universe so that the SEC can ensure compliance with accounting rules, mitigate risks to investors, and detect accounting fraud or other forms of corporate wrongdoing.

In a Toppan Merrill webinar broadcast on September 18, 2019, three experts from different markets sectors discussed XBRL’s success story:

  • Mike Willis, Assistant Director of the SEC’s Office of Structured Disclosure.
  • Emily Huang, CEO and co-founder of idaciti (which makes tools for analyzing structured data). Ms. Huang explained how Inline XBRL brings a company’s financials to life and how painfully apparent XBRL mistakes are to investors and analysts.
  • Mike Schlanger, Vice President of Solution Sales at Toppan Merrill. Mr. Schlanger offered best practices for filing high-quality XBRL disclosures.

Today, we'll cover how 100% XBRL coverage has transformed SEC review and enforcement.

To listen to the full webinar, click here. 

100% XBRL coverage has transformed SEC review and enforcement

100% XBRL coverage has transformed SEC review and enforcement XBRL has transformed SEC review capabilities, according to SEC regulator Mike Willis, Assistant Director of the SEC’s Office of Structured Disclosure. With
XBRL filings, the SEC staff now has—inhouse—100% coverage of reporting companies and of financial disclosures in structured-data format. This is a 7- to 10-fold increase in the coverage that was previously available from commercial sources of financial data in structured form. This enhancement has given the SEC staff unprecedented oversight in filer reviews and enforcement activities.

XBRL-tagging mistakes and inappropriate extensions can be detected immediately. Assessments of errors in XBRL quality are included in the review and comment process for a registrant. “SEC staffers have called vendors and registrants on specific data-quality errors,” Mr. Willis noted. “If your phone has not rung, good for you. But it has rung for others, including vendors.”

First stop for enforcement investigators

XBRL has also greatly enhanced the SEC staff’s reporting-compliance
assessments. Machine-readable XBRL tags are directly linked to the underlying FASB codification. That, Mr. Willis observed, enables identification of missing, incomplete, or inconsistent disclosures. “With a mouse-click, we can now identify what’s not in a financial report.” SEC enforcement investigations use XBRL filings heavily. “Due to the granular nature of structured disclosures,” he warned, “XBRL disclosures are the first stop for an enforcement investigation of financial statements.”

Narrative disclosures monitored for troubling signals

The SEC is also using machine learning to monitor the narrative portions of financial reports. “We’re monitoring the tonality of the narrative disclosures and comparing the tonality of the narrative disclosures with the related disclosures to identify inconsistencies as a signal for closer review,” explained Mr. Willis.

Data shared with the IRS and other agencies

“We are performing economic and market analyses. We are able to aggregate data. It is very useful to monitor changes in overall cash, effective tax rates, geographic trends, etc.” He revealed that the SEC shares the machine-readable datasets with other agencies and standards organizations, such as the IRS, the US Census Bureau, the US Bureau of Economic and Business Affairs, the Federal Reserve Board, the FASB, the IASB, and others.

XBRL mistakes send disturbing signals to the SEC and the market

While poor XBRL quality distorts a company’s financial story, Mr. Willis noted, it is not entirely useless to investors. Just as bad XBRL is a beacon for SEC review and enforcement staff, it may function as a lighthouse, warning investors away from rocky accounting controls and shallow corporate governance. “Those issues provide very useful and often very interesting insights about filers’ choices, reporting processes and controls, and sometimes their absence,” he observed. “Some data-quality errors require very subjective assessments, and they provide significant insights into the company’s judgment.”

Overuse of custom extensions
One example Mr. Willis gave of an XBRL warning flag is the excessive use of custom extensions instead of standard XBRL tags from the US GAAP taxonomy. When the percentage of custom extensions exceeds the average in the
company’s sector by double or more, it is a red flag not just for SEC staff but also for analysts and investors.

“Excessive and inappropriate extensions are wildly obvious to the user,” he warned. “They say a lot about the filer. As a result, filers should pay very close attention if they’re in that bucket. We see extensions for property, plant
equipment, cash, and other disclosures where we should not see them.”

Another big red flag is incorrect tag selection. For example, SEC staff sometimes finds that “gross revenue disclosures are tagged with the defined-benefit discount rate—completely inappropriate!” Missing XBRL tags are an even bigger gaffe. “That raises a question in the analyst’s mind about whether the filer even has adequate reporting processes and controls.”

To read the most recent issue of DIMENSIONS, click here. 

Share

Share on twitter Share on linkedin Share on facebook
Previous ArticleNew SEC Proposal to Modernize Filing Fee Disclosure and Payment Methods
Next ArticleHow to Give Easy Online Access to Your Medicare EOC

Subscribe

Subscribe

Subscribe

Subscribe

Toppan Merrill


Toppan Merrill, a leader in financial printing and communication solutions, is part of the Toppan Printing Co., Ltd., the world's leading printing group, headquartered in Tokyo with approximately US$14 billion in annual sales. Toppan Merrill has been a pioneer and trusted partner to the financial, legal and corporate communities for five decades, providing secure, innovative solutions to complex content and communications requirements. Through proactive partnerships, unparalleled expertise, continuous innovation and unmatched service, Toppan Merrill delivers a hassle-free experience for mission-critical content for capital markets transactions, financial reporting and regulatory disclosure filings, and marketing and communications solutions for regulated and non-regulated industries. With global expertise in major capital markets, Toppan Merrill delivers unmatched service around the world.


toppanmerrill.com


Show more posts from author

SEC; Capital Markets & Compliance; Dimensions; Periodic & Interim Reporting;
 

Expert Support

The best-in-class partner for complex, secure communications. Contact Toppan Merrill today.

Contact Us

Subscribe to the Toppan Merrill Blog

Gain actionable insight on industry trends, best practices & successful strategies to help your business.

Subscribe

Blog Categories

  • Industry Trends
  • Shareholder Communications
  • 40 Act SEC Regulations
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect
  • Content Management
  • Print/Fulfillment

Blog Categories

  • Industry Trends
  • Shareholder Communications
  • 40 Act SEC Regulations
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect
  • Content Management
  • Print/Fulfillment

Blog Categories

  • Member Communications
  • Section 508 Compliance
  • Digital Communications
  • Toppan Merrill Connect

Blog Categories

  • Industry trends
  • Shareholder communications
  • 40 act SEC regulations
  • Digital communications
  • Toppan Merrill connect
  • Content management
  • Print/fulfillment

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Most Popular Articles

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar
Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

Regulatory Resources

  • SEC Resources
  • EDGAR Resources
  • XBRL Resources

Toppan Merrill Corporate Video

2023 Compliance Calendar

Toppan Merrill 2023 Compliance Calendar_DIGITAL_Page_01
Download

Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

2022 Interactive Digital Compliance Calendar

View Calendar

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

Latest Blogs

ToppanMerrill logo

Expand Possible.

twitter linkedin

Solutions

  • Capital Markets Transactions
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Corporations
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Investment Management Companies
  • Financial Services Marketing & Communications
  • Health Insurance Marketing & Communications
  • Election Services

Technologies

  • Toppan Merrill Connect™
  • Toppan Merrill Bridge™

Blog

  • Insights

About Toppan Merrill

  • About Toppan Merrill
  • Operating Principles
  • Careers

Get In Touch

  • Contact Us

TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY NOTICE | TOPPAN MERRILL SERVICES AGREEMENT | TOPPAN MERRILL SUPPLIERS | GLOSSARY

© Toppan Merrill 2022

ToppanMerrill logo
Expand Possible.
` twitter linkedin
Solutions
  • Capital Markets Transactions
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Corporations
  • Regulatory Disclosures for Investment Management Companies
  • Financial Services Marketing & Communications
  • Health Insurance Marketing & Communications
  • Election Services
Technologies
  • Toppan Merrill ConnecTM
  • Toppan Merrill BridgeTM
BLOG
  • Insights
About Toppan Merrill
  • About Toppan Merrill
  • Operating Principles
  • Careers
Get In Touch
  • Contact Us

TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY NOTICE | TOPPAN MERRILL SERVICES AGREEMENT | TOPPAN MERRILL SUPPLIERS | GLOSSARY

© Toppan Merrill 2019